Spike buck question?
- Boogieman1
- 500 Club
- Posts: 6590
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 11:18 pm
- Status: Offline
Spike buck question?
I ran into the game warden this morn on my way home from work at the donut shop. I asked him a question that has been nagging me for years and he didn't have a answer so I know a lot of u guys are pretty knowledgeable with this type stuff, so was hoping someone could shine some light on it for me. In the county I hunt u are allowed 2 bucks, 1 with a spread of 13 inch or better and 1 spike. I have never seen a spike over 1.5 and even a lot of 1.5 year old meet the antler minimum. Why would u make the laws to intentionally target the younger age class? I visited a deer farm last summer in hopes to buy some giant sheds to make a chandelier, while I was there I asked if he ever has spike off spring. He said yes, it's usually due to late births or some time of sickness. It has no reflection of how the deer will look if u let him reach his potential. Im not from one of the states where young deer is all u can hope for, I just wanna know what the logic is behind this?
Life is hard; It’s even harder if you are stupid.
-John Wayne-
-John Wayne-
- thwack16
- 500 Club
- Posts: 2037
- Joined: Thu Aug 06, 2015 2:07 pm
- Location: MS
- Status: Online
Re: Spike buck question?
To my knowledge, Texas is the only state that allows it in this form. Though, a "prime" wma or two here in ms will give out spike tags and they are allowed to be taken under our DMAP program if the spikes are under a certain length (I think 3").
The thought process on taking out spikes stems from taking out the lowest potential bucks from the herd to keep them from taking the groceries and breeding opportunities from the higher potential bucks.
It is a very ignorant thought process and has long been disproved, but a few biologist are apparently still holding onto it.
Here's the progression of a buck in a study that Mississippi State did. I hate to link fb, but this is the only place I could find this study.
https://m.facebook.com/theqdma/photos/a ... 8939858775
The thought process on taking out spikes stems from taking out the lowest potential bucks from the herd to keep them from taking the groceries and breeding opportunities from the higher potential bucks.
It is a very ignorant thought process and has long been disproved, but a few biologist are apparently still holding onto it.
Here's the progression of a buck in a study that Mississippi State did. I hate to link fb, but this is the only place I could find this study.
https://m.facebook.com/theqdma/photos/a ... 8939858775
- Hawthorne
- 500 Club
- Posts: 6217
- Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2014 2:13 pm
- Location: michigan
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
We see the occasional spike in southern Michigan where they aren't common. They usually have small bodies compared to a yearling 6 or 8 point. They are late born fawns imo. They've had spikes turn into booners in controlled environments. I hate when I hear guys say they shot a small buck because it had poor genetics.
- vtbuck
- 500 Club
- Posts: 2560
- Joined: Tue Nov 01, 2011 4:43 pm
- Location: ne wi
- Contact:
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
Stupid people making stupid laws/rules. Just my opinion.
Perfection is a dream, practice is hard work, and achieving a goal is making that goal a reality.
-
- 500 Club
- Posts: 7865
- Joined: Tue Dec 09, 2014 12:54 pm
- Location: Medon Tn
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
Several big game laws make absolutely no since. I think people who come up with some of the hunting laws have never been hunting.
Several areas ive hunted are 9 point or better which is insane since most mature bucks are 8 points. Dunno who came up with that one either.
I would be crying if i let a 140 inch 8 point walk because he is too small to shoot!
Several areas ive hunted are 9 point or better which is insane since most mature bucks are 8 points. Dunno who came up with that one either.
I would be crying if i let a 140 inch 8 point walk because he is too small to shoot!
Never give up Freedom for imagined safety.
- Stanley
- Honorary Moderator
- Posts: 18734
- Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2011 4:18 am
- Facebook: None
- Location: Iowa
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
Just because you can doesn't mean you should.
You can fool some of the bucks, all of the time, and fool all of the bucks, some of the time, however you certainly can't fool all of the bucks, all of the time.
- DEERSLAYER
- Super Moderator
- Posts: 8352
- Joined: Sun Mar 14, 2010 3:22 pm
- Location: Western L.P. of MI
- Contact:
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
It's just ignorance.
You cannot invade mainland America. There would be a rifle behind every blade of grass.
Isoroku Yamamoto, Japanese Admiral
Isoroku Yamamoto, Japanese Admiral
- magicman54494
- 500 Club
- Posts: 4188
- Joined: Fri Feb 26, 2010 6:05 pm
- Location: central and northern WI
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
i believe your error is in assuming that there is logic used in law making.
Misty River Trackers base camp : https://www.facebook.com/groups/307702256717984/
Misty River Trackers You tube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCl5aA6 ... qd_bJAJl0A
Misty River Trackers You tube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCl5aA6 ... qd_bJAJl0A
- bowfreak8
- 500 Club
- Posts: 599
- Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2017 2:58 am
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
I hear this line of thinking far too often.
- SMS79
- Posts: 71
- Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2017 6:01 am
- Location: Georgia
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
Tennhunter3 wrote:Several areas ive hunted are 9 point or better which is insane since most mature bucks are 8 points.
??? I've heard some of these lines of thinking before, and can even see some points being made (though I don't agree with them), BUT that sounds like potentially the most counterproductive "QDMA" practice I've ever heard. 9pt or better? I'm not considering sticker/trash points in this, but that would mean you're targeting deer with at least one G4. If the goal is to grow "quality" racks, under that rule, the 2.5 & 3.5 yr old 9pt+ just became the #1 hit list bucks of the vast majority of the deer hunting population...because they're the visible deer with G4's. On the flip side of the coin, I'm looking at pics right now of a 6.5 yr old 8pt that may score 130 if he's lucky, and there is no telling how many younger bucks with G4's & better potential that he has run off the property because we have been unable to take him out. Can't imagine an actual good reason for it to be illegal to shoot a deer like that. Along that same line of thinking, down here in GA there are some counties with antler restrictions that include a minimum 15" inside spread. My uncle shot a 5.5 or 6.5 yr old 8pt a few years ago that had an 11" inside spread....and 11" G2's. Not a great score, but a super-cool, old buck with alot of character and uniqueness to his rack. That buck would have been illegal by the letter of the law in one of those counties. Hopefully a game warden would have some common sense in a situation like that.
- Horizontal Hunter
- 500 Club
- Posts: 2936
- Joined: Thu Jul 31, 2014 1:08 pm
- Location: Western Massachusetts
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
vtbuck wrote:Stupid people making stupid laws/rules. Just my opinion.
This is the root cause for sure. Living where I live I learned a long time ago not to try to apply common sense and/or logic to the laws. All it will do is leave you confused and agitated.
Bob
Vegetarian: vejiˈte(ə)rēən/noun: old Indian word for lousy hunter.
Excalibur Exocet, GT Laser II, 2" Bhoning Blazers 125g NAP Spitfire
Excalibur Exocet, GT Laser II, 2" Bhoning Blazers 125g NAP Spitfire
- Jonny
- 500 Club
- Posts: 5755
- Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2016 3:11 am
- Location: In a van down by the river
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
Couple years ago a buddy shot a spike that dressed 210. Wish I still had the picture. That one either had some serious injuries or some messed up genetics, but body size said it was a mature buck. I also know a couple guys who have shot some seriously big spikes off their farms. Some pushing 10-12" in length, and they were mature deer. Would never say they should make a spike tag, but yeah messed up genetics do happen, and if they reproduce, they do come around again. My family has a dozen or so racks of bucks without brow tines. One or two is one thing, but a dozen shows me that it is genetics in our area.
But a spike tag just seems stupid. Then again, how many deer hunters are actually writing deer hunting related laws?
But a spike tag just seems stupid. Then again, how many deer hunters are actually writing deer hunting related laws?
You have a monkey Mr. Munson?
- woodswalker
- 500 Club
- Posts: 606
- Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2016 5:32 am
- Facebook: don't do face book
- Location: Pennsylvania
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
I have seen spike bucks with 12 or 13 inch antler lengths and a wide spread and they were mature deer. I have also seen buck with very wide and high antlers several years in a row that were 4 pointers or Y buck, it was easy to tell it was the same deer that were mature deer and they could not be shot except by a junior, senior handicapped or military hunter on leave because where I hunt it is minimum of 3 points on at least one side. There are some deer that will be the same year after year and will never get better with age.
Life is short, eat dessert first!
-
- Posts: 28
- Joined: Sun Jun 22, 2014 12:57 am
- Location: Texas
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
Texas Parks and Wildlife Dept. did a big study years ago that determined a 1.5 yo spike buck will never (or rarely) catch up to a comparable 1.5 yo that has a forkhorn or greater. You can look up Kerr WMA study if you want to read all the scientific details. Readers digest version is they trapped wild deer in Texas, put them in a controlled environment to closely control breeding for many generations. They were also all given the same high quality diet with optimum protein. Basically they showed that nutrition not being a factor a 1.5 yo spike will usually never "catch up" with a forkhorn buck based on genetics. Again, the diet fed these deer were optimal. Since many counties in Texas are 2 buck counties they decided to allow one "quality" buck and the option of shooting a second buck that most likely would not catch up to the others.
In reality I doubt that enough spikes are taken each year to make a significant change in genetics however. Also since this study was only with Texas deer it may not necessarily apply to other areas. I'm not sure if other states have done any similar studies.
I personally do not shoot spikes since I hunt for mature bucks. Does eat better anyway!
In reality I doubt that enough spikes are taken each year to make a significant change in genetics however. Also since this study was only with Texas deer it may not necessarily apply to other areas. I'm not sure if other states have done any similar studies.
I personally do not shoot spikes since I hunt for mature bucks. Does eat better anyway!
- Boogieman1
- 500 Club
- Posts: 6590
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 11:18 pm
- Status: Offline
Re: Spike buck question?
I've read all these studies and they just leave me scratching my head. Quite honestly think they are just trying to sell u the bill of goods they cooked up. They supposedly did a 10 year breeding study for my area and concluded a peak breeding date which isn't even remotely close to anything I have witnessed.
Life is hard; It’s even harder if you are stupid.
-John Wayne-
-John Wayne-
-
- Advertisement
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: BLEXbot, KLEMZ and 79 guests