I think that is a 1.5 with spectacular genetics. Not just good - great. Looks like a 9 pointer? That's like 1 in 100 yearlings probably....good chance he would be B&C by age 3 or 4.
The only yearling I have ever personally seen with more than 8 typical points was a basket racked 10. I am pretty sure I was on the same buck the following year, he grew to a 140 class 2 year old and then jumped to a 170 class 3 year old.
On the flip side, I have seen some 2 year olds with racks that small....high camera angles make it tough to judge body size but he looks pretty thin for 2.
At the end of the day though, shoot what makes you happy.