I read this thread years ago but missed the recent bump. I'm bumping it again. It's one of the best on the forum IMHO.
I figured I'd share an experience from years past. This is the private drainage property that I hunt. At the time I shared it with another bowhunter who rode 4 wheeler to his stand. I didn't have gun rights and it got POUNDED every year and walked multiple times during shotgun and muzzy seasons.
Pre-Beast I was big on funnels. I had a stand location at x1 and I hunted it with a SE wind. I accessed across the south side of the field from East to West. My thoughts were a big buck would want to stay near cover while cruising and I'd catch one skirting the field edge. Real nice trail there and a couple scrapes too
Over the course of a couple years, and maybe 6 hunts from this stand, I had two occasions where I bumped a buck from the low spot (circled in pink) after an evening hunt.
Notice the topo lines. That is a big bowl right off that finger. They could eat beans and stay hidden. Pretty confident the bucks were shooters.
I knew I needed to re-scout that area, and I also happened to join the Beast that year. Nearing the end of the finger it got substantially thicker, plus there was a dead fall. Seeing this, I knew those bucks I saw were laying right there. Sure enough there were a couple beds and some rubs. Then I found some staging rubs. I don't find lots of rubs on this property, so finding 5 or 6 rubs in a 75 yard stretch was a big deal. They were on broom handle sized saplings.
I prepped a new tree at x2. There are beds North and West of me in those ravines and I could cover multiple trails as they exited. I wasn't in a great position for the buck bed itself, but how else do you hunt it?
. If he popped out on my side of the finger he'd be at 40 yards and could easily feed closer. NW wind is prevailing here and the obvious choice. I also consider it the best wind for the yellow dot bed.
I set Dad up at one of my existing sets by standing corn, and I headed to x2 even though the beans were combined and field was plowed. The hunt was more for my Dad than myself, but I figured it was worth a shot. To be honest I kind of felt like I was wasting a hunt...
It was pretty calm and I snuck painstakingly slow through the crunchy leaves in the field. The bed was only 50 yards away and in a depression. When I prepped it I sat in the bed and knew I couldn't hang the stand higher than 12' up or he'd see me. It was VERY early when a basket 8 popped up on the field edge. He stood and scanned for danger for several minutes then followed the edge right to me. Had a 10 yard shot at him.
While accessing I noticed some bean regrowth. They were maybe 1/2" tall and very sparse. Several feet between seedlings. Even though that field looked barren of food, I watched him go plant to plant and nip them off. Of course he eventually got my wind, but I could have killed him long before that.
Even though it wasn't a big buck, I know big bucks use that bed and the same scenario could easily unfold.
Haven't been back there since.