for once my opinion differs a lot from the general public on here..
Anyway, I have begun hunting a certain type of rub and have succeded by having the largest buck of my archery career under me at 15 feet. I also had many pictures of him using this trail, a few daylights and also ANOTHER large mature buck using the same trail that came under me when it was too dark to know what deer it was.
No other deer used this trail expect 2 mature bucks, the does and small bucks moved 50-80 yards away regulary.
I DO NOT ever hunt scrapes, I wasted years hunting scrapes with nothing to show for it, or even seeing a mature buck. Scrapes are a dime a dozen around here, but big rubs? not so much.
If I find a large rub, I immedialey scout the surrounding area for more (to form a rub line, or trail in my eyes) and determine why this obviously large deer put so much work in making this giant rub and rubs.
Say what you want about rubs, but find some large ones in an area you suspect a buck and you might have some luck.
This is one of 3 like rubs forming a "buck trail" thorugh thick over parallel from where other deer traveld.
Here is my stand overlooking the trail, I could get in here without ever crossing 1 trail. The buck stoped at the tree infront of me while I was at full draw looking down on his rack and neck... 1 more step is what I needed, but he caught my scnet and turned around.
This one came under right after shooting light, smae buck trail same rub line.
heres the big boy, have multiple daylight pictures of this buck using this trail, had him at 15 feet... still looking for him in a different spot. I beleive the spot was burnt only after he caught my scent, howvere I hunted this site multiple times because i NEW he was in the area, and IF he traveled the chances where very good he would use this trail.